Skip to main content

Review: Duel

Written by Jessixa Bagley
Illustrated by Aaron Bagley
New York: Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers, 2023. Comics. 307 pages.

Lucy and GiGi are sisters who are constantly fighting. When a big fight on the first day of school lands them in the principal's office, the sisters decide to settle things once and for all with a big fencing bout in front of the whole school. If GiGi wins, Lucy will stay out of her way until GiGi goes to high school and if Lucy wins, then GiGi will stop bullying her. GiGi is an experienced fencer and one of the best on the school team whereas Lucy is talented but her skills are more basic. As they prepare for their duel, the story is told from both sister's perspective which helps the reader understand how we got here and why we should empathize with both girls. Lucy and GiGi's father has recently passed away and their mother has withdrawn into her grief. The already strained relationship between the two sisters is now heightened by their complex emotions and grief. As the big bout comes closer, both Lucy and GiGi are having second thoughts, but is it too late to back out now?

Fencing is at the center of this story, but this is really a story about the relationship between sisters and what happens when that relationship is fraught with problems. At first glance, this book looks like a run of the mill graphic novel but this is really an emotionally complex exploration of grief, sisterhood, love, and forgiveness. As a graphic novel, this book works really well. The artwork is simple and tonal and integrates well with the text. Though a little text-heavy at points, the plot keeps the story moving forward. Lucy and GiGi are biracial with a Black father and a white mother. Good for fans of realistic graphic novels who aren't afraid of shedding a couple tears.



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Review: Umami

  Umami By Jacob Grant New York: Viking, an imprint of Penguin Random House LLC, 2024. Picture Book. Umami is a little penguin who is sick of eating the same thing everyday, cold fish --ugh! She becomes determined to find new foods and flavors, so Umami begins a journey across the sea in search of something different to eat. She reaches a place with a plethora of delicious options, and tries bitter, sweet, sour, and foods with umami (just like her name!) among others. Umami decides to bring all these delicious new flavors back for the other penguins to try in a feast. But, will the other penguins enjoy this new experience?  Filled with charm and humor, Umami is a diverse romp through a universal experience --am I willing to try something new? What will it be like? The idea of trying new foods and flavors make it especially relatable, and the appealing illustrations will have many readers ready to hop out on a culinary adventure. A humorous and sweet ending, caps off this delig...

Review: Faker

Faker By Gordon Korman New York: Scholastic Press, 2024. Fiction. 214 pages. 12-year-old Trey is used to starting over at a new school -- he has the routine perfectly memorized: make new friends, introduce his dad to the wealthy parents of his new friends, and "Houdini" themselves out of there before they get caught running their latest scam. Trey's dad is a master con artist, and Trey has just been promoted to full-partner. Their new scheme for the next big score brings them to the affluent suburb of Boxelder, TN where Trey's dad has cooked up a fake electric car company for investors to buy into. The only problem is that Trey is starting to grow tired of moving around and never putting down roots, especially after forming a fast friendship with Logan and developing a crush on Kaylee, a socially conscious girl in his class. As Trey longs for a normal life, is there any way he can convince his dad to get out of the family business? Gordon Korman is a perennial favorit...

Five Faves: Picture Books with Festive Treats

In my family, December marks the beginning of the holiday season, where we get to spend time together and do all of our favorite traditions. And, of course, eat lots of yummy food. I love that holidays look different for different families, but so many families have special foods they eat during the holidays. These are some of my favorite picture books about families making (and eating!) special holiday treats. These books might even give you new ideas of festive treats to try! The Last Tamale Written by Mendiola Orlando Illustrated by Teresa Martinez New York: Harper, 2024. Picture Book. Once a year, Luis' whole family gets together for their annual tamalada -- a party where they make tamales using a super-secret recipe. It's all love, family, and tradition until there is only one tamale left. Who will get it? It's an all-out family battle to decide who gets the last tamale. Colorful and humorous, this story is perfect for the holidays or whenever your family likes to enjo...