Skip to main content

Your Favorite Children's Book Characters... in a Whodunit!

By

Everyone loves a good whodunit.

What's a whodunit? It's a mystery where you don't know who the criminal is until the very end. Usually, there are specific types of characters in a whodunit that make it extra fun to read.

So what if we threw some of your favorite children's book characters together into one whodunit mystery? Who would be cast as the criminal? Who would be the detective? Who would be the unsuspecting victim? Here's what I came up with. 

The Detective: Nate the Great

Obviously, I could have chosen Nancy Drew or Cam Jansen or a myriad of other children's book detectives, but Nate the Great is my choice because he would figure out the case while eating pancakes with his faithful dog Sludge. Every good mystery needs pancakes. 

The Unsuspecting Victim: Curious George

What can I say? He was just too curious. 

The Butler: Waldo

Who's more suspicious than a person you can never find? I think Waldo would make the perfect butler.  He's well-mannered and has an uncanny ability of blending into a crowd, making him an excellent candidate for the criminal. After all, everyone knows the butler is always at the top of the suspect list. 

The Maid: Amelia Bedelia

Every whodunit needs a maid. Usually, the maid is quiet and mild, so why not spice things up a bit and have a maid who mixes everything up? Plus, she would make a great suspect. For example, did Amelia get mixed up when someone told her she made a "killer pie?" 

The Rich Heiress: Fancy Nancy

Fancy Nancy would be sure to add some flair to the mix of suspects. She would be perfect as the rich, young heiress who faints at the sight of blood and uses exciting words like, "le meurtrier!" (Which is a fancy way of saying, "the murder!") 

The Crazy, Eccentric Millionaire: Willy Wonka

I feel like there is always a millionaire in whodunits. Maybe they are the victim who bites the dust because the villain wanted their money. Or maybe they are a prime suspect because they are crazy enough to do anything.

The Cook: Mrs. Piggle Wiggle

Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle would make a spunky, delightful cook in a whodunit. She would also be a great co-detective with all of her creative solutions! Or... would she make the ultimate villain with all of those crazy ideas?

And finally...

The Criminal: Olivia

Sure, she looks like an innocent, darling, little pig. But those are the best kinds villains in whodunits-- the ones you least suspect! Plus, have you ever noticed that the only color in the Olivia series is RED? Coincidence? I think not. 

What do you think? Would these characters make a good whodunit? Who would you have chosen as the bad guy? Try writing your own mystery using characters from your favorite books and see how it turns out! Who knows? You could become the next great mystery writer. 
Labels:

Comments

Ms. Yingling said…
I would absolutely read this!
February 17, 2022 at 2:32 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Painting for Peace in Ferguson

By
Painting for Peace in Ferguson By Carol Swartout Klein Treehouse Publishing Group, 2015. Nonfiction. When the city of Ferguson was overrun with so much hate and despair that homes and businesses had to be boarded up to protect property, citizens of the community decided to bring a message of hope by painting the boarded windows. Klein’s rhyming text supports the photographs of the hundreds of artists and volunteers and their artwork as they bring the messages of peace, hope, love, and that by being united they can make a difference. A great book to show children how a community rallied to make a positive change and that even a small gesture can make a huge difference. A great discussion opener on how we should treat each other.
Post a Comment
Read more

Dragon Run

By
Dragon Run by Patrick Matthews Scholastic, 2013.  336 pgs.  Fantasy      Al Pilgrommor is excited for Testing Day, when he will receive his rank, a tattooed number on the back of his neck, and a path forward to his future occupation and life.  He feels confident because his parents were fours on a scale of seven, but he is worried for his friend Wisp who doesn't have much of a chance of scoring above a two at best. But when Al is scored a zero, he not only has no prospects, he may lose his life as the dreaded Cullers are unleashed to kill him and his family to purify the land's bloodlines.  Al's world is ruled by dragons--the lords and supposed creators of humankind--so he thinks that even if he survives, he will have to make his living as a beggar or thief. But when Al sticks up for his Earther friend in front of Magister Ludi, he is drawn into the struggle of a secret organization hoping to destroy the Cullers, and perhaps the dragons them...
1 comment
Read more

Review: Growing Home

By
Growing Home Written by Beth Ferry Illustrated by The Fan Brothers New York : Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers, 2025. Fiction. 261 pages. This book has some entertaining characters! We get to read about Toasty, the goldfish who loves to eat cheese puffs, Ivy, a plant with magical powers, and Arthur, the spider who ends up with a broken leg. Jillian is the main human character in the book. She loves Toasty and Ivy, and would probably love Arthur, too, but she doesn't know about him....yet. Her parents own an antique shop, but they are facing some economic hardship.  This charming story is about magic, teamwork, and friendship. I loved that there were all kinds of shenanigans happening. While we are on a journey where the fish, the plant, the spider, and the girl are working to solve one mystery after another, the author beautifully guides us to the realization that words are powerful, friendships can heal hearts, and books have their own magic power to help in all kinds ...
Post a Comment
Read more