Skip to main content

Your Favorite Children's Book Characters... in a Whodunit!

Everyone loves a good whodunit.

What's a whodunit? It's a mystery where you don't know who the criminal is until the very end. Usually, there are specific types of characters in a whodunit that make it extra fun to read.

So what if we threw some of your favorite children's book characters together into one whodunit mystery? Who would be cast as the criminal? Who would be the detective? Who would be the unsuspecting victim? Here's what I came up with. 

The Detective: Nate the Great

Obviously, I could have chosen Nancy Drew or Cam Jansen or a myriad of other children's book detectives, but Nate the Great is my choice because he would figure out the case while eating pancakes with his faithful dog Sludge. Every good mystery needs pancakes. 

The Unsuspecting Victim: Curious George

What can I say? He was just too curious. 

The Butler: Waldo

Who's more suspicious than a person you can never find? I think Waldo would make the perfect butler.  He's well-mannered and has an uncanny ability of blending into a crowd, making him an excellent candidate for the criminal. After all, everyone knows the butler is always at the top of the suspect list. 

The Maid: Amelia Bedelia

Every whodunit needs a maid. Usually, the maid is quiet and mild, so why not spice things up a bit and have a maid who mixes everything up? Plus, she would make a great suspect. For example, did Amelia get mixed up when someone told her she made a "killer pie?" 

The Rich Heiress: Fancy Nancy

Fancy Nancy would be sure to add some flair to the mix of suspects. She would be perfect as the rich, young heiress who faints at the sight of blood and uses exciting words like, "le meurtrier!" (Which is a fancy way of saying, "the murder!") 

The Crazy, Eccentric Millionaire: Willy Wonka

I feel like there is always a millionaire in whodunits. Maybe they are the victim who bites the dust because the villain wanted their money. Or maybe they are a prime suspect because they are crazy enough to do anything.

The Cook: Mrs. Piggle Wiggle

Mrs. Piggle-Wiggle would make a spunky, delightful cook in a whodunit. She would also be a great co-detective with all of her creative solutions! Or... would she make the ultimate villain with all of those crazy ideas?

And finally...

The Criminal: Olivia

Sure, she looks like an innocent, darling, little pig. But those are the best kinds villains in whodunits-- the ones you least suspect! Plus, have you ever noticed that the only color in the Olivia series is RED? Coincidence? I think not. 

What do you think? Would these characters make a good whodunit? Who would you have chosen as the bad guy? Try writing your own mystery using characters from your favorite books and see how it turns out! Who knows? You could become the next great mystery writer. 

Comments

Ms. Yingling said…
I would absolutely read this!

Popular posts from this blog

De la hora del cuento: La letra "F"

Cuentos Gustavo: el fantasmita timido Por Flavia Z. Drago Somerville, Massachusetts : Candlewick Press, 2020. Libro ilustrado. "Conoce a Gustavo. Ɖl es un fantasma y como a cualquier ser paranormal le encanta hacer lo que le es normal: atravesar paredes, hacer volar objetos y brillar en la oscuridad. TambiĆ©n le encanta tocar el violĆ­n. Pero Gustavo tiene un problema. Ɖl es muy, muy tĆ­mido, y aunque su deseo mĆ”s grande es tener amigos, nunca se ha atrevido a hablarle a ninguno de los monstruos en su pueblito. Con el DĆ­a de Muertos cerca, ¿se atreverĆ” Gustavo a dejar que lo vean?" --Editor Cuentitos ¡Yo sola! Por Sumana Seeboruth y Maribel Castells Concord : Barefoot Books, 2023. PequeƱo libro ilustrado. "Yo sola. ¡No, no, no! Puedo hacerlo. ¡Vete, vete, vete! Esta niƱa no quiere que la ayuden ... hasta que su hermana mayor necesita ayuda. ¡El trabajo en equipo es divertido!" --Editor Otros libros sobre la letra "F" El bosque en familia Maisy juega fĆŗtbol Lo...

From Story Time: The Letter "F"

Preschool Time Family of Friends Written by Varsha Bajaj Illustrated by Ishaa Lobo New York: Nancy Paulsen Books, 2025. Picture Book. Isha can't wait for her birthday party. Nani, her fun-loving grandmother, is coming all the way from India to be there! So when Nani has to postpone her trip, Isha is crushed. She no longer feels like celebrating. Fortunately, she has a whole neighborhood of friends to cheer her up, and they all work together to make her day truly special. This moving intergenerational story shows the impact that chosen family can have and is a wonderful reminder to appreciate all the important people in our lives. --Publisher Preschool Time Found By Salina Yoon New York: Walker Books for Young Readers, an imprint of Bloomsbury, 2014. Picture Book. Upon finding a toy rabbit in the forest, Bear tries his very best to return it to its home but by the time its owner appears, Bear has become attached to Bunny. --Editor Toddler Time On All Fours By Gaƫtan DorƩmus Brooklyn...

Review: Alina in Her Roots

Alina in Her Roots Written by Shenaaz Nanji Illustrations by Beena Mistry Toronto, ON : Second Story Press, 2026. J Intermediate. 91 pages. Alina is traveling by herself from her home in Canada to Nairobi, Kenya. But it's more than just a vacation to visit her favorite cousin Safi - Alina is on a secret mission to find her roots. Her family history started in India with her great-great-great-grandparents. Her parents were born in Kenya, then moved to Canada where she was born. She's heard stories about Kenya but wants to know where she fits in and to find what she is missing. Nairobi is a welcoming, vibrant, exciting place where so much feels so different. Alina writes journal entries to her Nani about her experiences, finding ways to make her own stories through matatu rides, trips to the market, a safari, and meals shared with new loved ones. This is a really well-written, cheerful and reassuring realistic fiction about the adventure of exploring different places and cultures...