Skip to main content

Donner Dinner Party

Donner Dinner Party
by Nathan Hale
Amulet, 2013. 123 pgs. Comics/Graphic Novels

     Nathan Hale's third book in his Hazardous Tales series is grimmer than the first two; a graphic novel that tastefully considers a graphic subject--the ill-fated Donner party. Hale's story makes abundantly clear how truly ill-fated they were, what with James Reed foolishly--even idiotically--leading them off onto the Hastings Cut-Off in spite of numerous warnings, and the later decision not to summit the Sierra Nevada range the day before the snows fell in earnest, not to mention the accidental and clearly murderous deaths that troubled the party even before that point.  Hale lifts the gloom as much as he can through the framing device of the original Nathan Hale's storytelling to his hangman and to the British captain. "What's cannonballism?" asks the disingenuous hangman, who is also brokenhearted over the loss of animals along the Donner's trail, but cares not a fig for the human deaths. Hale also gives the fainthearted a way out.  As the historical Nathan Hale tells his listeners that things actually do get much worse for the Donner party, he tells the squeamish to skip to page 113 to miss the worst of it. But there is a limit to what can be toned down about people who would not only eat their already dead companions, but kill others for the meat they would provide. Hale's latest Hazardous Tale (Threat Level:  Tragic) is, as we have come to expect, a work of extraordinary skill and restraint, terrible tragedy expertly retold with a judicious  and sensitive comic relief. Parents may wish to read this one first, or with their children.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

If You Like ... Super Silly Read Alouds

If you like super silly read alouds, these playful picture books are for you! Young readers get to laugh, imagine, and become part of the storytelling fun! From upside-down adventures and magical spells to silly surprises and unexpected telephone calls, each book offers something delightfully different. These books are sure to inspire giggles, curiosity, and plenty of conversation. Pandamonium! Written by Annie Bailey Illusrated by Bonnie Wong New York : Feiwel and Freinds, 2026. When the panda family gathers for a reunion, they attempt to take the perfect family photograph. Despite their best efforts to look their finest and sit still, the little pandas become increasingly wiggly and giggly. Fun panda facts at the end add an educational touch to this playful celebration of family togetherness. I Think We're Upside Down! By Marcus Cutler New York : G.P. Putnam's Sons, 2026. Rabbit and Raccoon discover that something is very wrong with their world. When Raccoon’s new basketball ...

De la hora del cuento: La letra "H"

  Cuentos Cuando tu niñera es una bruja Escrito por Ana Siqueira Ilustrado por Irena Freitas New York : Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers, 2022. Libro ilustrado. "Si consigues una nueva niñera y ya casi es Halloween, ten cuidado ... ¡porque podría ser una bruja!" --Editor Cuentitos Mi ofrenda Por Mariana Galvez   Los Angeles, California: Little Libros, LLC, 2022. Pequeño libro ilustrado. "Finalmente ha llegado el momento y Amelia necesita tu ayuda para recoger art̕culos para la ofrenda de su familia. A través del uso de colores, este libro de buscar y encontrar les enseñará a sus pequeños el significado especial que tienen los artículos cotidianos durante el Día de Muertos." --Editor Otros libros sobre la letra "H" Hola. ¡Adiós! Hermana pegajosa Hansel y Gretel ¡Hola, Capitán! Nuestras Ancestras: Tejiendo Historias En Mi Huipil

From Story Time: The Letter "J"

Preschool Time This Joy! By Shelley Johannes New York: Abrams Books for Young Readers, 2022. Picture Book. A young child tries to measure the size of her joy and the depth of her gratitude as she embraces the beauty of the day. --Publisher Preschool Time How Not to Make a Jelly Sandwich By Ross Burach New York: Scholastic Press, 2026. Picture Book. Readers follow five unconventional steps to make a simple jelly sandwich. --Editor Toddler Time Star in the Jar By Sam Hay and Sarah Massini Naperville, IL: Sourcebooks Jabberwocky, 2018. Picture Book. When a little boy stumbles across a lost star, he decides to take care of it, putting it in a jar and carrying it with him everywhere. But when the sky calls out for its missing star, can the little boy and his sister figure out a way to return the star to its friends in the sky ... even if it means saying goodbye forever? --Editor Book Babies I Need a Hug By Aaron Blabey New York: Cartwheel Books, an imprint of Scholastic, 2015. Board Book. A...