Skip to main content

Revolution is Not a Dinner Party

By

REVOLUTION IS NOT A DINNER PARTY; Ying Chang Compestine; New York: Henry Holt, 2007, 248 pages. Fiction
The title for Ms. Compestine's first novel for children is taken from a quote by Chairman Mao: "A revolution is not a dinner party, or writing an essay, or painting a picture, or doing embroidery; it cannot be so refined, so leisurely and gentle, so temperate, kind, courteous, restrained and magnanimous. A revolution is an insurrection, an act of violence by which one class overthrows another." And, in fact, all the niceties of civilized life are done away in China under Mao, as we learn in this new book based on Ms. Compestine's own experiences as a young girl in China. For middle-grade school children, this may be a mystifying story--why would Ling's father, a skilled surgeon, be taken from the operating theater and forced to work as a night janitor? Why should Ling's neighbors and friends be jailed because they have read books from England or America? What kind of school would study only from one book--the Little Red Book of Chairman Mao? Young people who have never heard of the Red Guard or the Gang of Four will learn plenty from this short novel about the cruelty and irrationality of life in Communist China. Ling is a feisty and sympathetic protagonist--her parents fears for her and themselves are chillingly portrayed, and the book is well-written and difficult to set aside, once begun. Revolution is Not a Dinner Party of necessity has some brutal scenes, and should probably be shared with older children. It might be well, also, for children to read the historical note at the back of the book before they begin the novel, in order to better understand what is going on.
Labels:

Comments

curlyq said…
This was an excellent read with a very interesting and engrossing subject. Definitely an great book choice for older readers. I stayed up all night to finish reading it!
April 29, 2008 at 4:59 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Funny Farm by Mark Teague 2009

By Anonymous
There are things I liked about Mark Teague's newest book, Funny Farm , and things I didn't like. Where should I start? I'll do the "didn'ts" first. The illustrations show animals personified. Well, some of the animals are. The main characters, Edward, and his farm family relatives, all dogs, are humanized. They stand upright, do farm chores, eat at a table, wear clothes, knit (yes, with paws) and sleep in beds. Most everybody else on and around the farm, who are also animals, act like animals. They are outside, roll in mud, live in the barn, and require care from their owners. It struck me the most on the page spread where there are pigs playing in puddle in the rain and Edward, a black and white boxer, watches from inside the house. I thought "You're a dog! Go play with them!" But, alas, he can't, seeing as how he goes through his entire visit to the farm wearing a suit and red bow tie. Another picture that bothered me was the maple syrup pa...
Post a Comment
Read more

Review: Super Boba Cafe

By
Super Boba Café By Nidhi Chanani New York: Amulet Books, 2023. Comics. 215 pages. 14-year-old Aria is excited to spend her summer in San Francisco getting quality time with her Nainai. She loves helping at her grandmother's Super Boba Café. But she can't help but notice that her grandmother is acting strange and secretive. She refuses to let Aria into the kitchen at all and she disappears at the same time each night without telling Aria where she goes. Meanwhile, Aria is eager to drum up more business for Super Boba Café. She gets a major windfall when the shop cat, Bao, surprises them by having kittens, and Aria realizes this is a major social media opportunity. She knows this will help Nainai's shop, but she is apprehensive to get back on social media after a terrible cyberbullying experience she had back home. As the shop starts to get busier, Nainai is more and more anxious about her secret project. This prompts Aria to investigate with help from her Nainai's neighb...
Post a Comment
Read more

Plain Kate

By
Plain Kate by Erin Bow Scholastic, 2010. 314 pgs. Fiction Katerina Svetlana is named after her mother, who died giving birth. Her father, Piotr the woodcarver, calls her plain Kate and she is soon known as Plain Kate, after the butcher's witticism, because she is "plain as a stick." But her father calls her Kate, my star. Piotr teaches his daughter to carve and she is on her way to becoming a master when her father dies of a strange sleeping sickness that plagues her town and the country round about. In a magical land, Kate has no magic but her skill. Still, she is so good her neighbors think her a witch and drive her away, but not before a real witch comes along and she trades him her shadow for the promise that she won't have to travel alone. He gives her a talking cat. Kate falls in with gypsies who also find reason to hurt and abandon her and she is rescued by the witch who takes her upriver in a terrible quest to avenge his dead sister and bring her back from...
Post a Comment
Read more