Skip to main content

Review: Return to Sender

Return to Sender
By Vera Brosgol
New York: Roaring Brook, 2025. Fiction. 320 pages.

Oliver Bakh and his mother have finally found a place to call home. After the unexpected death of his father, Oliver's mother fell into a deep depression, leaving Oliver to pick up the pieces and the pair moving from home to home. Now, things seem to be looking up, when Oliver's 96-year-old great-aunt Barb dies and bequeaths her Manhattan apartment to Oliver and his mother. Oliver starts attending an elite prep school filled with wealthy (often snobby) classmates who make Oliver feel embarrassed that he doesn't have the same expensive clothes and shoes as them. But then, a solution appears in an unlikely place -- Oliver discovers a magical mail slot in his apartment that grants his wishes. As Oliver and his new (also only) friend Collette begin to use the mail slot to grant their own wishes, they notice that every wish granted also has a adverse consequence. Can Oliver and Collette undo the damage and close the mail slot forever?

Vera Brosgol's first prose novel is an engaging and enticing read. Oliver is a likable protagonist, and readers who have experienced the unexpected death of a loved one will really identify with his yearning for his father. Despite the central theme of moving on after a loss, this book manages to avoid feeling too heavy thanks to a healthy dose of dark humor, a cartoonishly evil villain, and a touch of whimsy. Readers who might miss Brosgol's signature illustrations will enjoy spot illustrations to enhance the story. Add this sci-fi, magical realism, ethical adventure to a list of great stories about kids living in New York City.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Review: Fowl Play

  Fowl Play By Kristin O'Donnell Tubb New York: Katherine Tegen Books, 2024. Fiction 277 pages. Still reeling from her beloved uncle's death, Chloe Alvarez is comforted and confused when at his last will and testament reading, Uncle Will gifts her his African Grey parrot, Charlie. Charlie has a robust vocabulary and loves to make Alexa requests for her favorite songs, but when she starts saying things like, "homicide," and "cyanide," Chloe becomes convinced that Uncle Will may have met his demise by murder instead of a genetic disease, as was previously thought. Ultimately, bringing in her brother, Grammy, and Uncle Frank (and of course Charlie,) Chloe's ragtag and adoring family support her search for answers ---going on stakeouts, engaging in fast pursuits, and searching for clues. But as the suspects stack up and the mystery grows, Chole will learn that the process of death and grieving is complicated, and in the end her Uncle Will's words that, ...

Review: Blood in the Water

Blood in the Water By Tiffany D. Jackson New York: Scholastic, 2025. Fiction. 255 pages. 12-year-old Kaylani McKinnon can't help but feel like a fish out of water. She's a Brooklyn girl spending her summer on Martha's Vineyard surrounded by wealthy family friends in their mansion. All she really wants is to stay home all summer where she her incarcerated father can easily reach her, and she can keep working to find ways to prove him innocent of fraud and embezzlement. Despite her protests, she finds herself on the island with the snooty granddaughters of her host. Soon after Kaylani's arrival, a popular teen boy is found murdered and she decides to conduct her own investigation. As she tries to discover what happened to Chadwick Cooper, Kaylani finds that not everything on Martha's Vineyard is as perfect as it appears. Thrillers for middle grade readers can be hard to find, but Tiffany D. Jackson succeeds in her first middle grade novel. A quick moving plot, tight d...

Review: Alice with a Why

Alice with a Why By Anna James New York: Penguin, 2026. Fiction. 240 pgs. In 1919, in the aftermath of the first World War, Alyce is living with her grandmother in the English countryside. Her grandmother, also named Alice, tells Alyce (with a y) stories from her childhood adventures in a wonderful land filled with white rabbits and mad hatters. Alyce doesn't really believe the silly stories, she just misses her father who was killed in the war. One day, Alyce receives a mysterious invitation to tea, and subsequently falls into a pond where she is transported to Wonderland. Her grandmother, of course, is that Alice. Alyce is prompted by the Mad Hatter, Dormouse, and March Hare to seek out the Time Being and put an end to the war between the Sun King and the Queen of the Moon. Thus begins Alyce's adventure through Wonderland. I have a certain soft spot for the original story of Alice in Wonderland. It is one of my particular favorites and I often have a hard time reading new int...