Review: The Peach Thief

By Linda Joan Smith

Somerville, MA: Candlewick Press, 2025. 374 pages.

This entertaining historical fiction set in England in the 1850s totally consumed me. A young girl who is down on her luck wants to steal a peach from a local garden. While in the process, she gets caught! The head gardener mistakes her for a boy and puts her to work in the garden to make up for the crime she committed.

Scilla thinks she will be scrubbing pots for just a few days. The workload is heavy, but Scilla rises to the occasion. The longer she stays, the more Scilla feels like she might actually fit in. Most shockingly, she finds herself wanting to be part of the crew that works in the lavish garden. However, there are a few complications that get in the way. Can she actually make amends for the crime that landed her here in the first place? Will people be willing to overlook her standing in society and accept her into their family? If people discover she is really a girl, will that jeopardize any chances she has to fitting in?

I loved following Scilla on her adventurous journey to try to fit in and to find a place for herself. Multiple times while reading, I had to put the book down and take a few minutes to process all that was happening to Scilla and the people she comes to rely on for friendships. I would recommend this book for people who like a historical fiction, complicated friendships, redemption stories, or adventure. It left me hopeful and happy!

Comments

Stand Tall by Joan Bauer

Stand Tall By Siena Siegel by Joan Bauer Putnam, 2002, 182 pgs Realistic Fiction Tree is 12 years old and over 6 feet tall. That would be great if he were a basketball player, but he is not. Dealing with his unusual size is not Tree's only challenge. Tree's parents have recently gone through a divorce, and his grandfather has had his leg amputated as the result of an old Vietnam War injury. The strength of this book is the characterizations. All of the main characters are dimensional and sympathetic. Bauer sets the characters in real and often funny family situations. Best of all is the character of Tree. He is boy with a heart to match his stature. This is a great book for boys or girls ages 9-12, as a read aloud or for individual reading. This book could also be a good Rx book for children whose families are going through divorce, or for anyone who feels like they don't fit in.

Review: The New Girl

The New Girl By Cassandra Calin New York: Graphix, 2024. Comic. 261 pages. 12-year-old Lia and her family have just moved from Romania to Montreal, and she's doing her best to keep up with the changes. But, she's homesick. She misses the rest of her family, her friends, and her favorite Romanian treats. She doesn't speak French and her English is shaky, which makes it hard to make friends, even in her international immersion class. And she's dealing with super painful menstrual cramps every month. But before long, Lia starts to hit her stride. She befriends the other bilingual girls in her class, she gets a spot as the artist for her school's magazine, and even has a new crush -- Julien. Though she may be the new girl, Lia is starting to fit in. This slice of life graphic novel is an adorable choice for middle grade readers and young teens. Lia is a likable protagonist and readers will have little difficulty relating to her adjustment to school. The text speaks to a...

Review: Cincinnati Lee, Curse Breaker

Cincinnati Lee, Curse Breaker By Heidi Heilig New York: Greenwillow Books, 2025. Fiction. 291 pages. Thanks to Cincinnati Lee's no good, dirty rotten, artifact stealing great great great grandfather, Cincinnati's family is now cursed and Cincinnati feels like it's up to her to break the curse. Which involves trying to steal the artifacts back from museums that her grandfather robbed from graves and archeological sites around the world and return them to their countries of origin. But when Cincinnati's first artifact stealing mission goes awry, she decides it might be more effective to steal an all-powerful artifact herself that she can use to break the curse - The Spear of Destiny. Unfortunately her race for the spear will pit her against art smugglers and thieves intent on finding the ancient artifact themselves. If you are looking for an Indiana Jones read-alike, this is the perfect for you! Heavy on the adventure with similar levels of mysticism to those seen in th...

Provo Library Children's Book Blog

Search This Blog