Skip to main content

Review: Band Nerd

Band Nerd
Written by Sarah Clawson Willis
Illustrated by Emma Cormarie
New York: Harper Alley, 2025. Graphic novel. 258 pages.

 12-year-old Lucy Carver has been looking forward to starting at the Windley School of the Arts all summer. She is nervous about the academic challenge of a private school, but is excited to continue improving her flute skills. The flute is one thing that makes Lucy feel special - and distracts her from her challenging home life. Lucy's father is an alcoholic and his increasing arguments with Lucy's mother intensify Lucy's fears that if she isn't the best at the flute then she isn't good enough. Driven to be the best, Lucy fights for first chair flute in her school band, driving a wedge between her newly budding friendships.

Lucy's challenges with perfectionism and trying to hide a troubling home life will, unfortunately, ring familiar for many young readers. But, this graphic novel does a lot to approach a challenging and heavy topic with an honestly that makes it work really nicely for middle grade readers. Though the road to resolution isn't direct, readers see Lucy and her father seeking professional help with rehab and therapy. Readers who enjoy realistic graphic novels will find a lot of value in this book. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Painting for Peace in Ferguson

Painting for Peace in Ferguson By Carol Swartout Klein Treehouse Publishing Group, 2015. Nonfiction. When the city of Ferguson was overrun with so much hate and despair that homes and businesses had to be boarded up to protect property, citizens of the community decided to bring a message of hope by painting the boarded windows. Klein’s rhyming text supports the photographs of the hundreds of artists and volunteers and their artwork as they bring the messages of peace, hope, love, and that by being united they can make a difference. A great book to show children how a community rallied to make a positive change and that even a small gesture can make a huge difference. A great discussion opener on how we should treat each other.

Dragon Run

Dragon Run by Patrick Matthews Scholastic, 2013.  336 pgs.  Fantasy      Al Pilgrommor is excited for Testing Day, when he will receive his rank, a tattooed number on the back of his neck, and a path forward to his future occupation and life.  He feels confident because his parents were fours on a scale of seven, but he is worried for his friend Wisp who doesn't have much of a chance of scoring above a two at best. But when Al is scored a zero, he not only has no prospects, he may lose his life as the dreaded Cullers are unleashed to kill him and his family to purify the land's bloodlines.  Al's world is ruled by dragons--the lords and supposed creators of humankind--so he thinks that even if he survives, he will have to make his living as a beggar or thief. But when Al sticks up for his Earther friend in front of Magister Ludi, he is drawn into the struggle of a secret organization hoping to destroy the Cullers, and perhaps the dragons them...

From Story Time: Summer Week 5

  Stories in the Park Mousterpiece: A Mouse-Sized Guide to Modern Art By Jane Breskin Zalben New York: Roaring Brook Press, 2012. Picture Book. Janson the mouse, who lives in a museum, becomes an acclaimed artist by copying the styles of paintings she sees there. Includes notes about the artists and works featured. --Editor Stories in the Park Gray Written by Laura Dockrill Illustrated by Lauren Child Somerville, MA: Candlewick Press, 2024. Picture Book. Some days you may feel sunshine yellow or orange-balloon bright. Other days you're gray, or even night-sky black-like a dark scribble on a page, a storm in the clouds, or a puddle in the road. Gray is when you don't feel like yourself, or like you don't belong. But however you feel, there are big hugs (red) and loving lullabies (blue) waiting, and even the grayest sidewalk is a canvas for you to fill with the colors you choose. A tender narration from British spoken-word poet Laura Dockrill and subtle, spare artwork from fo...